Tyler Warren, the 2024 John Mackey Award winner from Penn State, joins the Indianapolis Colts, poised to break their tight end production drought. With a 93.4 PFF receiving grade and 2.78 yards per route run, Warren's versatility fits well in the Colts' run-heavy scheme. Competing mainly with Mo Alie-Cox, Warren is expected to secure a significant role, especially with Anthony Richardson's need for reliable targets. Despite the Colts' low pass rate, Warren's efficiency and route-running prowess make him a high-end TE2 candidate. His development hinges on Richardson's passing improvement, but Warren's immediate impact as a receiver is promising, offering a potential fantasy sleeper pick with a clear path to targets.