In 2025 dynasty rookie drafts, Tyler Warren and Colston Loveland present contrasting profiles. Warren, with an 88th percentile separation rate and a record-breaking college season, offers immediate impact but is hindered by a 14.6% drop rate and Anthony Richardson's deep-target tendencies in Indianapolis. Loveland, younger and more athletic, thrives in route efficiency and RAC ability, fitting Chicago's mismatch-driven scheme despite competition from Cole Kmet. While Warren's polished skills provide a safer floor, Loveland's age and dynamic skill set suggest a higher long-term ceiling. Dynasty managers should prioritize Loveland for future upside, especially if Chicago's offense evolves to maximize his unique traits, while Warren remains a solid option for immediate contributions.