James Cook is currently holding out from the Buffalo Bills' training camp, seeking a contract worth $15 million per year. This demand would make him one of the top four highest-paid running backs in the league. The Bills are hesitant to meet this demand due to several factors.
RB Market Volatility: The NFL's current trend is to avoid high salaries for running backs due to their injury risk and the availability of cheaper alternatives. For example, Kyren Williams signed a $11 million per year deal, highlighting the market's reluctance to pay more.
Depth and Alternatives: The Bills have drafted Ray Davis and retained Ty Johnson, providing them with younger, cost-effective options should Cook's holdout continue.
Team Philosophy: Buffalo prioritizes investments in their passing game and quarterback, viewing running backs as more replaceable assets.
In 2024, Cook had a career-best season with 1,009 rushing yards, 258 receiving yards, and 18 total touchdowns. If he signs, Cook is projected to maintain a lead role with approximately 1,000–1,100 rushing yards, 250–300 receiving yards, and 10–12 touchdowns in 2025. His fantasy value would place him as a late RB1/high RB2, assuming a healthy season.
If Cook's holdout persists, Ray Davis and Ty Johnson could see increased roles, potentially diminishing Cook's leverage and fantasy value. A trade remains a possibility but is not currently anticipated.
