The Indianapolis Colts face a critical decision for their Week 1 starting quarterback between Anthony Richardson and Daniel Jones. Both quarterbacks have shown promise and inconsistency in training camp, with the decision expected to hinge on preseason performances.

Anthony Richardson offers significant fantasy upside due to his rushing ability, projected for 480 rushing yards and 4.6 touchdowns in 2025. However, his passing remains a concern, with a projected 2,278.6 passing yards and 13.4 touchdowns. His "boom-or-bust" nature, combined with injury history, makes him a high-risk, high-reward option.

Daniel Jones, signed to a one-year, $14 million contract, provides a steadier presence with projected 3,160 passing yards and 12 touchdowns. His consistent practice performance, completing 81.3% of passes, positions him as a reliable, if limited, QB2 option in fantasy.

The Colts' decision will likely impact fantasy strategies, with Richardson being a potential QB1 due to his rushing, while Jones offers a safer floor as a QB2 in superflex leagues. The upcoming preseason game against the Packers is pivotal, as both quarterbacks will have the opportunity to solidify their case for the starting role.