The Indianapolis Colts' decision to start Daniel Jones over Anthony Richardson for the 2025 season reflects a strategic pivot towards stability. Despite fan frustration, the move aims to leverage Jones' experience in managing offensive operations, as highlighted by his $14 million contract and commitment from Coach Shane Steichen.

Daniel Jones is expected to provide consistent game management, reducing turnovers and maximizing in-structure execution. Although his past performance with 13 total touchdowns versus 16 turnovers raises concerns, the Colts believe his approach offers a safer floor in a competitive AFC South.

Anthony Richardson, with a 47.7% completion rate and 8-12 TD-INT ratio in 2024, remains a backup due to inconsistency and injuries. His potential remains untapped, and he could become a trade candidate if the Colts seek to re-evaluate their quarterback room in 2026.

This season is not a "wash" but a calculated attempt to stabilize the quarterback position, potentially sacrificing upside for reliability. The Colts' playoff odds (9th-best in AFC) suggest they are still competitive, banking on minimizing mistakes to stay in contention.